Memory is a funny thing, isn't it? How much of our actual past do we really remember and how much have we 'chosen' to forget? Not that everything isn't lodged somewhere in the cells of our brain and body, just that, due to events of our lives and our perceptions of those events, we seem to remember selectively.
Some remember people and events. I remember houses. I can remember almost every house I have lived in since the age of 5. That's a lot of houses over more years than I care to talk about. Until we moved here 12 years ago I had not lived in any one place more than 5 years - other than an 8 year stint in Mansfield.
My favorite house, the one I loved best of all, was in Peoria, Illinois. I have a picture of myself and my 2 younger brothers,(later there were 2 more) bundled up for winter on a sled in the front yard, and another of the 3 of us properly dressed and seated for a formal portrait. My brother John with his naturally curly ringlets in suit and tie, Don in his little jumper with buttons over a shirt with a full embroidered collar seated in a harge chair, and myself seated on the arm of the chair, my hair in tight ringlets which mother had used a curling iron to achieve. Gawd, we looked serious!
It was a big house. My brother John calls it a mansion and perhaps it was.
Here are my memories of it. A huge wrap around porch with porch swing. The front door opened to a large foyer with a winding staircase to the left. At the bottom of the staircase was a bay window, where the Christmas tree was put. I remember coming down the staircase to see the tree on Christmas morning and how beautiful it was. I still have an ornament from that tree, the only thing that remains of that house, that time, other than John.
To the right of the foyer was the formal living room. What I remember most about that room is that it is where my baby sister, Patricia Elizabeth, was laid out. Her tiny white coffin surrounded by flowers and candles in front of the fireplace, a china doll inside. I also remember my mother sitting in that room embroidering suspenders for John's dance recital costume. He was a Russian cossack, complete with fur hat. We both took ballet lessons. I vaguely recall wearing a tutu for a recital, however details evade me. I was much too shy and self-conscious (for many years, actually). An example of selective memory?
Behind that room was another large room. I seem to think it was a formal dining room but am not sure. What I do recall of it was that my maternal grandmother had placed a blue Christmas tree on a table. How odd a blue Christmas tree seemed to me.
Across from that was the dining room, which had another fireplace, and behind that the kitchen. To the right, opening off those rooms, was the sunroom. I loved that room and have always wanted one. Maybe someday. I recall my mother sitting and rocking in that room, probably holding a baby.
In the kitchen was another stairway going up to the second story - the servents stairway - although we never had servents. Actually we didn't own the house. I don't remember my parents ever owing a house.
The upstairs I don't remember quite as well. I know there was a long hallway with a large bathroom on the left. I well remember Grandpa's razor strop since it was liberally applied in cases of misbehavior. My parents room was at the back on the right side of the hall. I recall it was a nice sized room, large enough to include a crib for the youngest child. The head of the bed was against the back wall, with an opening on each side of the bed leading into the nursery, which is where John and I slept. The closet was on the left of the bed and had a door at the back leading into the hallway. In the closet was an old linotype machine of my fathers - about the size of an old typewriter. Our teenage aunts and uncle used to enter the closet from the hall and tap on the keys of the linotype. Needless to say I didn't know how anyone got into the closet and the sounds scared my - I was sure it was ghosts. Those same aunts and uncle also enjoyed 'pulling the rug' from under our feet. The floors were hardwood with lots of small rugs which were used for that sport.
Other things I remember from that house era: A huge snowball bush in the front yard which I loved to play and hide under; an old fashioned black wrought iron fence; mother fixing soft fried eggs with toast cut into small strips for dunking into the yolk; walking to the drug store for a popsicle or fudgecicle; milk delivered by a milkman; my father being overwrought and panicked with concern over some illness John had; going to kindergarten at Catholic school and having to stand in the corner for some unremembered infraction - more selective memory? (For the sake of convenience hereinafter referred to as (s/m). I'm sure John will have other memories to share when we talk next. For now, for me, this is enough. Please come back for part II, if you are interested.
Monday, July 12, 2010
Saturday, July 3, 2010
FAMILY MATTERS
When I was working for the Division of Family Services, the term 'dysfunctional family' was frequently used in an attempt to explain, mitigate, or at least comprehend the behaviors viewed as outside the norm. Child abuse or neglect? Dysfunctional family. Incest? Rape? Domestic violence? Alcoholism? Drugs? Dysfunctional family, right? I even bought into all of that - for a while. What does the term even mean? What is a family? What defines those parameters? And what is meant by dysfunction? Who is setting the standards and values by which we can measure dysfunction? Furthermore, are these variables strictly 'family matters' that happen to impinge on societies values and therefore demand our attention? Does family even matter anymore? As seems to be the case here I have more questions than answers. So where to begin?
I think it used to be much easier to define family than it is now. A family was once basically defined as mother, father and children, with grandparents, aunts, uncles, etc. The 'traditional' family unit. Now we refer to nuclear family, extended family, blended family, single parent family, same sex parents family, adopted family, and more. Even these groupings are nebulous, fluid, ever changing. Members come and members go through marriage, divorce, birth, death, so the family unit, as a whole is not a static entity. Nor, I might add, do family values remain static. Divorce, adultry,same sex relationships, choosing to have a child out of wedlock, pregnancy before marriage, co-habitation, inter-racial relationships, are just some examples of values once considered unacceptable and which are now part of the cultural norm. Not equally acceptable to all yet not cause for the furor once associated with them.
So who decides which family values are acceptable? Is it the politicians who demand adherence to the old traditional 'family values' while committing adultry or engaging in inappropriate sexual relations with subordinates of either sex; is it the 'old men in long dresses' of the Catholic Church who deny women the right to family planning, who refuse to allow priests to marry, who continue to subjugate women to lesser status within the church hierachry, who deny, cover up and protect those priests who sexually abuse children; is it the fundamentalist religious leaders, be they Christian, Jewish, Islamic, or any other ideology who, in their zealotry, seek to stamp out - whether by intimidation, force, or death - those whose opinions differ? In light of the patriarchal culture within which we live I would say all of the above.
Which is not to say that there are'nt some family (cultural and societal) values which overarch those more fluid variables mentioned above. For me rape, incest, molestation of children in whatever form that may occur, and domestic violence fall into that category; they have no place in any configuration of family. They are behaviors which violate, diminish, and demean all parties involved. By which I mean not only the victim and the abuser, but also those who stand by and allow those behaviors to occur and continue without having the moral fortitude to make a stand against them. If family does matter how is it that we can allow these behaviors to continue?
Which brings me to dysfunctional family. As mentioned before, I used to buy into that concept however I've to come to believe it is an irrevelant label and one which is a disservice to those to whom it is applied. The concept of dys-function implies an ability to function according to accepted norms. I have come to believe that all family units - traditional, single parent, bi-racial, whatever - are functioning to the best of their ability whether that meets accepted norms or not. No doubt every family has challenges, yet they are still functioning at their own level of ability. This does not mean steps cannot be taken to aid families in increasing their level of functioning. It only means they should be acknowledged for doing their best given their circumstances. So what about those families in which those variables I mentioned in the preceeding paragraph are occurring? Rape, incest, violence, etc. Slapping the label 'dysfunctional family' on them is useless. Intervention (when needed to protect from physical abuse), education, incarceration; being pro-active in not allowing situations to escalate, are some answers that come to mind. Simple, not easy. I've no magic potion to solve these issues however since I do believe that family matters I have chosen to bring it up. Hopefully others with more skills, wisdom and insights than I possess will take action.
Why bring all of this up now? In recent days I have been made aware that a close family member has been physically abused by a step-son. The parent of said abuser has chosen to enable him through her denial of the enormity of the acts and by prohibiting the victim from pressing charges. Both the parent and the victim continue to allow the abuser access to their home, continue to bail him out of jail, continue to condone the behavior, and on and on ad nauseum. The matter reached the point of no return when the victim chose to put the egregious wishes/demands of his spouse, the mother of his abuser, ahead of a simple request by his only biological child. This is but a small, although personal, example of what could be termed a 'dysfunctional family'. Yet, despite the fact that these behaviors, which are inappropriate, unacceptable, immoral, not to mention illegal, this family still functions to the best of their ability and seems quite content to continue to do so. To me, despite the fact that I see nothing more I can do at this time, these are family matters, and, to me, this family matters.
I think it used to be much easier to define family than it is now. A family was once basically defined as mother, father and children, with grandparents, aunts, uncles, etc. The 'traditional' family unit. Now we refer to nuclear family, extended family, blended family, single parent family, same sex parents family, adopted family, and more. Even these groupings are nebulous, fluid, ever changing. Members come and members go through marriage, divorce, birth, death, so the family unit, as a whole is not a static entity. Nor, I might add, do family values remain static. Divorce, adultry,same sex relationships, choosing to have a child out of wedlock, pregnancy before marriage, co-habitation, inter-racial relationships, are just some examples of values once considered unacceptable and which are now part of the cultural norm. Not equally acceptable to all yet not cause for the furor once associated with them.
So who decides which family values are acceptable? Is it the politicians who demand adherence to the old traditional 'family values' while committing adultry or engaging in inappropriate sexual relations with subordinates of either sex; is it the 'old men in long dresses' of the Catholic Church who deny women the right to family planning, who refuse to allow priests to marry, who continue to subjugate women to lesser status within the church hierachry, who deny, cover up and protect those priests who sexually abuse children; is it the fundamentalist religious leaders, be they Christian, Jewish, Islamic, or any other ideology who, in their zealotry, seek to stamp out - whether by intimidation, force, or death - those whose opinions differ? In light of the patriarchal culture within which we live I would say all of the above.
Which is not to say that there are'nt some family (cultural and societal) values which overarch those more fluid variables mentioned above. For me rape, incest, molestation of children in whatever form that may occur, and domestic violence fall into that category; they have no place in any configuration of family. They are behaviors which violate, diminish, and demean all parties involved. By which I mean not only the victim and the abuser, but also those who stand by and allow those behaviors to occur and continue without having the moral fortitude to make a stand against them. If family does matter how is it that we can allow these behaviors to continue?
Which brings me to dysfunctional family. As mentioned before, I used to buy into that concept however I've to come to believe it is an irrevelant label and one which is a disservice to those to whom it is applied. The concept of dys-function implies an ability to function according to accepted norms. I have come to believe that all family units - traditional, single parent, bi-racial, whatever - are functioning to the best of their ability whether that meets accepted norms or not. No doubt every family has challenges, yet they are still functioning at their own level of ability. This does not mean steps cannot be taken to aid families in increasing their level of functioning. It only means they should be acknowledged for doing their best given their circumstances. So what about those families in which those variables I mentioned in the preceeding paragraph are occurring? Rape, incest, violence, etc. Slapping the label 'dysfunctional family' on them is useless. Intervention (when needed to protect from physical abuse), education, incarceration; being pro-active in not allowing situations to escalate, are some answers that come to mind. Simple, not easy. I've no magic potion to solve these issues however since I do believe that family matters I have chosen to bring it up. Hopefully others with more skills, wisdom and insights than I possess will take action.
Why bring all of this up now? In recent days I have been made aware that a close family member has been physically abused by a step-son. The parent of said abuser has chosen to enable him through her denial of the enormity of the acts and by prohibiting the victim from pressing charges. Both the parent and the victim continue to allow the abuser access to their home, continue to bail him out of jail, continue to condone the behavior, and on and on ad nauseum. The matter reached the point of no return when the victim chose to put the egregious wishes/demands of his spouse, the mother of his abuser, ahead of a simple request by his only biological child. This is but a small, although personal, example of what could be termed a 'dysfunctional family'. Yet, despite the fact that these behaviors, which are inappropriate, unacceptable, immoral, not to mention illegal, this family still functions to the best of their ability and seems quite content to continue to do so. To me, despite the fact that I see nothing more I can do at this time, these are family matters, and, to me, this family matters.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)